Baby Carrier Types Compared — Which One Is Right for You?
Baby Carrier Types Compared — Which One Is Right for You?
So many carriers, so many opinions. If you've started researching and ended up more confused than when you began — this guide is for you. An honest, practical breakdown of the main types, with no brand bias.
Stretchy wraps. Woven wraps. Structured carriers. Mei tais. Ring slings. Hip seats. The world of babywearing has more options than most new parents expect — and the sheer volume of information online can quickly turn excitement into overwhelm.
We've been through it ourselves. When we were expecting, we spent hours comparing carriers, reading forum threads, and watching YouTube tutorials — only to feel less certain than when we started.
So here's the guide we wish we'd had. We'll walk through the main carrier types — what they are, what they're good at, and where they fall short. Honestly, without trying to sell you anything.
(Spoiler: we'll also tell you which one we ended up loving most — but we'll explain why, and you can make up your own mind.)
The main types of baby carriers
Stretchy wrap
A long piece of stretchy, jersey-like fabric — typically 4 to 5 metres — that you wrap around yourself and your baby in a specific pattern. Popular for the newborn phase for its snug, womb-like carry.
- Newborns and tiny babies
- Very close, snug carry
- Often quite affordable
- Comfortable on both shoulders
- Limited to lighter babies (up to ~7–8 kg)
- Can feel hot in summer
- Takes practice to wrap correctly
- Long fabric is tricky on the go
Woven wrap
Similar to a stretchy wrap in concept, but made of woven (non-stretch) fabric. Beloved by experienced babywearers for its versatility and weight distribution. Comes in lengths from size 2 to size 7+.
- Excellent weight distribution
- Works for all ages and sizes
- Many carry positions
- Grows with your child
- Steeper learning curve
- 5–6 metres of fabric to manage
- Higher price points for quality
- Washing requires more care
Structured carrier (SSC)
The buckle-and-strap carrier most people picture when they think "baby carrier." A padded panel with waist belt and shoulder straps. Brands like Ergobaby, Babybjörn, and Manduca are well-known examples.
- Easy once adjusted and fitted
- Good for longer carries
- Both shoulders bear the weight
- Many parents find it intuitive
- Bulky — takes up bag space
- Often needs newborn insert
- Takes time to get fit right
- Can feel stiff and gear-like
Mei tai
A traditional Asian-inspired carrier: a fabric panel with long straps at each corner — two to tie around your waist, two to cross over your shoulders. A hybrid between a wrap and a structured carrier.
- Adaptable to different body types
- No buckles — fabric only
- Good for back carries
- Often more breathable than SSCs
- Requires learning to tie correctly
- Less quick than ring sling or SSC
- Less common — fewer tutorials
- Bulkier than a ring sling
Ring sling
A single length of fabric threaded through two rings, worn over one shoulder. Adjusts instantly by pulling fabric through the rings. Works from newborn all the way to toddler — no replacement carriers needed.
- On and off in seconds
- Newborn to ~3 years (15 kg)
- All carry positions
- Lightweight — fits in any bag
- Discreet nursing cover
- Works with any outfit
- Asymmetric (one shoulder)
- Takes 2–3 tries to master tightening
- Not ideal for very long hikes
Side by side: a quick comparison
| Carrier type | Newborn ready | Toddler ready | Weight | Learning curve | Packability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stretchy wrap | ✓ Yes | ✗ No | Light–medium | Moderate | Folds, but bulky |
| Woven wrap | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes | Medium–heavy | High | Large bundle, can get messy when using outside |
| Structured (SSC) | usually no, either specifically newborn carrier (usually for up to 3-4 months) or with insert | ✓ Yes | Heavy | Low–moderate | Bulky |
| Mei tai | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes | Medium | Moderate | Folds, medium, can get messy when using outside |
| Ring sling | ✓ From day one | ✓ Yes, up to 15 kg | < 350 g | Low (2–3 tries) | Fits in any bag |
So which one should you choose?
There's no universal answer — and anyone who tells you otherwise is trying to sell you something. The right carrier depends on your body, your baby, your lifestyle, and how you like to move through the world.
That said, here's a simple way to think about it:
- If you love wrapping and have the patience to learn — a woven wrap is unbeatable for comfort over long periods.
- If you want something buckle-based and easy — a structured carrier is a solid choice, especially if someone else (partner, grandparent) will also be using it.
- If you want one carrier that does everything, from newborn to toddler, fits in your bag, and works with your wardrobe — a ring sling is hard to beat.
"The ring sling is the one carrier we always come back to. Not because we make one — but because of what it genuinely offers: simplicity, versatility, and that heart-to-heart closeness, without the bulk."
— The Moon Sling team, AmsterdamWhy we chose linen for the ring sling
If you decide a ring sling is right for you, material matters more than you might expect. Most ring slings on the market are made from cotton or cotton blends. We chose 100% linen — and it wasn't an arbitrary decision.
Linen is naturally temperature-regulating. In summer, it breathes and keeps you both cool. In winter, it holds warmth when layered. It's a single layer of fabric between you and your baby — no padding, no synthetic filling, nothing that traps heat.
And crucially: it gets softer with every wash. Something cotton blends don't quite do in the same way. After a few months of use, it drapes beautifully and feels completely different from when it was new.
It's also machine washable, dries quickly, and is made from flax — a plant that needs no pesticides and very little water. Slow fashion, made to last.
A note on safety
Whatever carrier you choose, safe positioning is the most important thing. The T.I.C.K.S. rule is a good starting point:
- Tight — The sling should be snug, with baby held close to your body.
- In view at all times — You should always be able to see your baby's face.
- Close enough to kiss — Baby's head should be close enough to kiss on the top.
- Keep chin off chest — Always ensure a clear airway; chin should not be pressed to chest.
- Supported back — Baby's back should be supported in its natural curve.
With a ring sling specifically, the M-position (knees higher than bottom, legs in a natural frog pose) is recommended for healthy hip development — and it's the position a ring sling naturally creates when worn correctly.
If you're new to ring slings and want to go deeper on safety, we've written a detailed post on the most common fear: "I'm scared my baby will fall out" — debunking the #1 ring sling myth.
Ready to try a ring sling?
Moon Slings are made from 100% Linen, designed in Amsterdam, and handmade in the EU. From newborn to 15 kg — one sling, every stage.
Explore Moon Slings — EUR 89 →
Leave a comment
Please note, comments must be approved before they are published